design-patterns

Original source / Raw SKILL.md

---
name: design-patterns
description: Use when designing software architecture, refactoring code structure, solving recurring design problems, or when code exhibits symptoms like tight coupling, rigid hierarchies, scattered responsibilities, or difficult-to-test components. Also use when choosing between architectural approaches or reviewing code for structural improvements.
---

# Design Patterns

## Overview

Design patterns are proven solutions to recurring software design problems. They provide a shared vocabulary for discussing design and capture collective wisdom refined through decades of real-world use.

**Core Philosophy:** Patterns are templates you adapt to your context, not blueprints to copy. Use the right pattern when it genuinely simplifies your design—not to impress or over-engineer.

## Foundational Principles

These principles underpin all good design:

| Principle | Meaning | Violation Symptom |
|-----------|---------|-------------------|
| **Encapsulate What Varies** | Isolate changing parts from stable parts | Changes ripple through codebase |
| **Program to Interfaces** | Depend on abstractions, not concretions | Can't swap implementations |
| **Composition Over Inheritance** | Build behavior by composing objects | Deep rigid class hierarchies |
| **Loose Coupling** | Minimize interdependency between objects | Can't change one thing without breaking another |
| **Open-Closed** | Open for extension, closed for modification | Must edit existing code for new features |
| **Single Responsibility** | One reason to change per class | Classes doing too many things |
| **Dependency Inversion** | High-level modules don't depend on low-level | Business logic coupled to infrastructure |

## Pattern Selection Guide

### By Problem Type

```
CREATING OBJECTS
├── Complex/conditional creation ──────────→ Factory Method
├── Families of related objects ───────────→ Abstract Factory
├── Step-by-step construction ─────────────→ Builder
├── Clone existing objects ────────────────→ Prototype
└── Single instance needed ────────────────→ Singleton (use sparingly!)

STRUCTURING/COMPOSING OBJECTS
├── Incompatible interface ────────────────→ Adapter
├── Simplify complex subsystem ────────────→ Facade
├── Tree/hierarchy structure ──────────────→ Composite
├── Add behavior dynamically ──────────────→ Decorator
└── Control access to object ──────────────→ Proxy

MANAGING COMMUNICATION/BEHAVIOR
├── One-to-many notification ──────────────→ Observer
├── Encapsulate requests as objects ───────→ Command
├── Behavior varies by internal state ─────→ State
├── Swap algorithms at runtime ────────────→ Strategy
├── Algorithm skeleton with hooks ─────────→ Template Method
├── Reduce N-to-N communication ───────────→ Mediator
└── Sequential handlers ───────────────────→ Chain of Responsibility

MANAGING DATA ACCESS
├── Abstract data source ──────────────────→ Repository
├── Track changes for atomic commit ───────→ Unit of Work
├── Ensure object identity ────────────────→ Identity Map
├── Defer expensive loading ───────────────→ Lazy Load
├── Map objects to database ───────────────→ Data Mapper
└── Shape data for transfer ───────────────→ DTO
```

### By Symptom

| Symptom | Consider |
|---------|----------|
| Giant switch/if-else on type | Strategy, State, or polymorphism |
| Duplicate code across classes | Template Method, Strategy |
| Need to notify many objects of changes | Observer |
| Complex object creation logic | Factory, Builder |
| Adding features bloats class | Decorator |
| Third-party API doesn't fit your code | Adapter |
| Too many dependencies between components | Mediator, Facade |
| Can't test without database/network | Repository, Dependency Injection |
| Need undo/redo | Command |
| Object behavior depends on state | State |
| Request needs processing by multiple handlers | Chain of Responsibility |

### Domain Logic: Transaction Script vs Domain Model

| Factor | Transaction Script | Domain Model |
|--------|-------------------|--------------|
| Logic complexity | Simple (< 500 lines) | Complex, many rules |
| Business rules | Few, straightforward | Many, interacting |
| Operations | CRUD-heavy | Rich behavior |
| Team/timeline | Small team, quick delivery | Long-term maintenance |
| Testing | Integration tests | Unit tests on domain |

**Rule of thumb:** Start with Transaction Script. Refactor to Domain Model when procedural code becomes hard to maintain.

## Quick Reference

### Tier 1: Essential Patterns (Master First)

| Pattern | One-Line | When to Use | Reference |
|---------|----------|-------------|-----------|
| **Strategy** | Encapsulate interchangeable algorithms | Multiple ways to do something, swap at runtime | [strategy.md](patterns/strategy.md) |
| **Observer** | Notify dependents of state changes | Event systems, reactive updates | [observer.md](patterns/observer.md) |
| **Factory** | Encapsulate object creation | Complex/conditional instantiation | [factory.md](patterns/factory.md) |
| **Decorator** | Add behavior dynamically | Extend without inheritance | [decorator.md](patterns/decorator.md) |
| **Command** | Encapsulate requests as objects | Undo/redo, queuing, logging | [command.md](patterns/command.md) |

### Tier 2: Structural Patterns

| Pattern | One-Line | When to Use | Reference |
|---------|----------|-------------|-----------|
| **Adapter** | Convert interfaces | Integrate incompatible code | [adapter.md](patterns/adapter.md) |
| **Facade** | Simplify complex subsystems | Hide complexity behind simple API | [facade.md](patterns/facade.md) |
| **Composite** | Uniform tree structures | Part-whole hierarchies | [composite.md](patterns/composite.md) |
| **Proxy** | Control access to objects | Lazy load, access control, caching | [proxy.md](patterns/proxy.md) |

### Tier 3: Enterprise/Architectural Patterns

| Pattern | One-Line | When to Use | Reference |
|---------|----------|-------------|-----------|
| **Repository** | Collection-like data access | Decouple domain from data layer | [repository.md](patterns/repository.md) |
| **Unit of Work** | Coordinate atomic changes | Transaction management | [unit-of-work.md](patterns/unit-of-work.md) |
| **Service Layer** | Orchestrate business operations | Define application boundary | [service-layer.md](patterns/service-layer.md) |
| **DTO** | Shape data for transfer | API contracts, prevent over-exposure | [dto.md](patterns/dto.md) |

### Additional Important Patterns

| Pattern | One-Line | When to Use | Reference |
|---------|----------|-------------|-----------|
| **Builder** | Step-by-step object construction | Complex objects, fluent APIs | [builder.md](patterns/builder.md) |
| **State** | Behavior changes with state | State machines, workflow | [state.md](patterns/state.md) |
| **Template Method** | Algorithm skeleton with hooks | Framework extension points | [template-method.md](patterns/template-method.md) |
| **Chain of Responsibility** | Pass request along handlers | Middleware, pipelines | [chain-of-responsibility.md](patterns/chain-of-responsibility.md) |
| **Mediator** | Centralize complex communication | Reduce component coupling | [mediator.md](patterns/mediator.md) |
| **Lazy Load** | Defer expensive loading | Performance, large object graphs | [lazy-load.md](patterns/lazy-load.md) |
| **Identity Map** | Ensure object identity | ORM, prevent duplicates | [identity-map.md](patterns/identity-map.md) |

## Common Mistakes

| Mistake | Symptom | Fix |
|---------|---------|-----|
| **Pattern Overuse** | Simple operations require navigating many classes | Only use when solving real problem |
| **Wrong Pattern** | Code feels forced, awkward | Re-examine actual problem |
| **Inheritance Abuse** | Deep hierarchies, fragile base class | Favor composition (Strategy, Decorator) |
| **Singleton Abuse** | Global state, hidden dependencies, hard to test | Use dependency injection instead |
| **Premature Abstraction** | Interfaces with single implementation | Wait for real need to vary |

## Anti-Patterns to Recognize

- **God Object:** One class does everything → Split using SRP
- **Anemic Domain Model:** Objects are just data bags → Move behavior to objects
- **Golden Hammer:** Same pattern everywhere → Match pattern to problem
- **Lava Flow:** Dead code nobody removes → Delete it, VCS has your back

## Modern Variations

| Modern Pattern | Based On | Description |
|----------------|----------|-------------|
| **Dependency Injection** | Strategy + Factory | Container creates and injects dependencies |
| **Middleware** | Decorator + Chain of Responsibility | Request/response pipeline |
| **Event Sourcing** | Command | Store state changes as events |
| **CQRS** | Command/Query separation | Separate read/write models |
| **Hooks (React/Vue)** | Observer + Strategy | Functional lifecycle subscriptions |

## Implementation Checklist

Before implementing a pattern:

- [ ] Pattern solves a real problem in this codebase
- [ ] Considered simpler alternatives
- [ ] Trade-offs acceptable for this context
- [ ] Team understands the pattern
- [ ] Won't over-engineer the solution